Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere ?

Anything shooting related including law and procedure questions.

Moderator: dromia

Forum rules
Should your post be in Grumpy Old Men? This area is for general shooting related posts only please.
Message
Author
Duey
Posts: 343
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 6:33 pm
Home club or Range: Offas Dyke, Pickering, North Cotes Butts and Grove small arms
Location: Brookenby, Lincolnshire

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#11 Post by Duey »

With 22” barrel I would guess that you would at best achieve the 2800fps but probably not much better without getting close to dangerous pressures
Also Remington brass will have a different internal volume than that of the Lapua brass I use and that will effect powder weights to pressures achieved, I noticed this particularly in my 300 winmag which I originally obtained Lapua brass for this, which then became obsolete so switched to other brands of brass and resulted in a reduction of powder weight to keep reloads safe ( was 10yrs back now so details evade me )
Maggot

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#12 Post by Maggot »

Born Again wrote:Thanks for the pointers. I'm glad to see N140 mentioned as that's what I'm currently using (42.9gn, 168SMK, 71mm OAL, Fed210M). I also have a tub of RL15 unopened.
I dont suppose this will help, and no doubt some wag will say its not worth a fig but...

I cannot see how you could get a node calculator given that even 2 identical rifles may behave differently, sadly practical testing is the only real way forward. You could shoot a ladder test that (if shot accurately) will give you an idea for the nodes, where you could start doing a load test proper. Barrel length and stiffness is a huge factor, as is anyhing stuck on the end and how it is bedded/rested. MY dolphin was up about the 3150-3200 mark (over HME as were the majority of FTR rifles then) using palma brass, RS52 and a 30" lilja barrel. The latter only had 3 grooves and shot fast. These speeds were clocked by several indipendant chronos but my point is that it was a specialist application that took some thinking about and lots of testing...which I hate and is a PITA teanews and why I take "accuracy" loads with a pinch of salt because they may have been right for the test rifle, but meaningless in another.

I dont get that you NEED to push a bullet past 2800 FPS for an accurate load as again, it depends on your application. Long range FTR then I get it but otherwise. My 16" barrelled AR is accurate enough with a relatively low load of 42.5 or 43 grains of RS52 but it wont get used past 600 yards. There are many accurate .303 rifles shooting about 2440 ONO.

You may do well to try some of the RS powders such as RS52. They are a more modern powder that give better velocity for less powder and less spikey pressures.

The 168 thing goes back to the SMK 168 HPBT that was designed as a 300m bullet, so would not have to be "Booted" hard to stay supersonic at 1000. As a result it has quite a steep and short boat tail compared with a lot of the 155 Palma bullets. By default it used to usually get upset at long ranges and as was the custom back then, if something was good, it got copied, so a lot of 168 HPBT bullets were direct copies of the 168 SMK.

Bottom line, test. Dont get hung up over chronos etc, just test as you would be shooting. The data you will get back is realtime and worth its weight in gold ;)
Born Again

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#13 Post by Born Again »

Maggot wrote:Bottom line, test. Dont get hung up over chronos etc, just test as you would be shooting. The data you will get back is realtime and worth its weight in gold ;)

You're right of course, I was looking for a shortcut that probably doesn't exist. Thanks for nudging me back towards "reality" cheers .
Racalman
Full-Bore UK Supporter
Posts: 731
Joined: Tue Mar 11, 2014 8:21 am
Home club or Range: LPSC and NRA
Location: Berkshire
Contact:

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#14 Post by Racalman »

Is this the sort of thing you're looking for?
223 load development.JPG
You can find the spreadsheet here:

http://www.65guys.com/load-development-analysis/
Born Again

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#15 Post by Born Again »

Racalman wrote:Is this the sort of thing you're looking for?
Not what I was looking for, but more useful I think. Bookmarked for later study, thanks.
Maggot

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#16 Post by Maggot »

Born Again wrote:
Maggot wrote:Bottom line, test. Dont get hung up over chronos etc, just test as you would be shooting. The data you will get back is realtime and worth its weight in gold ;)

You're right of course, I was looking for a shortcut that probably doesn't exist. Thanks for nudging me back towards "reality" cheers .
Sadly mate the only way to be sure. You might be able to take some short cuts later down the line if something changes as you will have a decent known ballpark but otherwise.
User avatar
ovenpaa
Posts: 24689
Joined: Fri Nov 05, 2010 8:27 pm
Location: Årbjerg, Morsø DK
Contact:

Re: Accuracy Node Calculator - is there a free one somewhere

#17 Post by ovenpaa »

The Ruger M77 is a fine and oft underrated rifle and should teach you some valuable shooting and reloading lessons. I used to shoot a 24" barrelled 7,62x51 with a 16X 'scope out to 1000 yards and more, you really do need to know every trick in the book to be even vaguely competitive at theses distance and I learnt so much about re-loading, wind reading and general shooting and it was probably one of the key motivators for me when I first started making reloading gauging for myself so many years ago.
/d

Du lytter aldrig til de ord jeg siger. Du ser mig kun for det tøj jeg har paa ...

Shed Journal
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests